The ecommerce landscape is experiencing a dramatic shift, driven by completely new consumer expectations and generational differences in shopping behaviors. Route’s State of Ecommerce Report reveals critical insights into how brands can adapt to these changes and build stronger customer relationships in order to grow in an increasingly competitive market.

Get the Full Report →

The New Reality: One Bad Experience Can Cost You a Customer

Today’s consumers have little tolerance for shipping mishaps. Our research shows that 28% of shoppers would permanently abandon a brand after just one negative shipping experience. This number jumps to 38% among Gen Z shoppers, highlighting the growing importance of reliable post-purchase experiences for younger consumers.

Even more telling: 97% of shoppers now expect automatic refunds or replacements when packages are lost, stolen, or damaged. This expectation for immediate resolution has become the new standard, particularly among younger generations who prioritize transparency and real-time communication throughout the shipping process.

The Rise of “Wardrobing” and Its Impact on Retail

A fascinating trend has emerged in the form of “wardrobing” – the practice of purchasing items with the intent to return them after short-term use. Our data shows significant generational differences in this behavior:

This trend is particularly prevalent during the holiday season, with Millennials leading at 5.3% planning to engage in wardrobing, followed closely by Gen Z at 4.8%.

The Psychology Behind Returns: What Makes Customers Buy (or Not)

Return policies are proving to be a crucial factor in purchase decisions:

– 75% of consumers are less likely to return items when restocking fees apply

– 63% would reconsider purchasing from brands that impose these fees

– 53% find short return windows a deterrent to buying

These statistics underscore a clear message: flexible, customer-friendly return policies are no longer optional – they’re essential for building trust and encouraging purchases.

Black Friday & Cyber Monday: Changing Shopping Patterns

The holiday shopping landscape is evolving, with Gen Z leading significant changes:

– 26% of Gen Z shoppers plan to increase their spending this year (double the average across all age groups)

– 59% of all shoppers plan to make purchases in the first few days of sales

– Direct-from-brand shopping is expected to see a 3.4% increase in 2024

Where Consumers Plan to Shop

Traditional retail giants maintain their dominance, but new players are emerging:

– Amazon: 83.2% (↑0.6%)

– Walmart: 65.1% (↑0.9%)

– Target: 44.9% (↑0.5%)

– Direct from brands: 37.2% (↑3.4%)

– Temu: 13.8% (↑1.6%)

Key Takeaways for Brands

Prioritize the Post Purchase Experience: With one negative experience potentially costing you a customer forever, investing in stronger carrier partnerships, transparent and proactive communication, and simple issue resolution is crucial.

Adapt Your Return Policies: Consider implementing flexible return windows and minimizing restocking fees to increase purchase confidence.

Plan for Early Holiday Shopping: With most consumers shopping in the first few days of sales, ensure your promotional strategy targets the early birds.

Focus on Price and Authenticity: 56% of consumers cite better prices as their primary reason for shopping directly from brands, followed by confidence in authenticity (43%).

Looking Ahead

As the ecommerce landscape continues to evolve, brands must adapt to meet changing consumer expectations. The post purchase experience is now a critical differentiator, with successful brands focusing not only on creating loved products but also on making every interaction after checkout convenient and easy.

This report is based on a survey of 1,250 consumers conducted by Route in October 2024, representing a cross-section of U.S. consumers across various demographics.